Download Projecto em Engenharia Informatica

Transcript
Chapter 6. Conclusions
65
it has only 3 permissions for each user or group: read, write and manage. Unlike Alfresco,
Nuxeo comes in a single fully featured package. Additionally, for paying costumers, besides the professional support, Nuxeo includes a payed platform (included in professional
support) that allows, using a drag and drop and textbox GUI, to easily and quickly costumize Nuxeo.
Alfresco mentions that Nuxeo is not its competitor, in an e-mail I got as an answer
but I don’t believe that is true. They have nearly the same features. The differences are
limited to details. It doesn’t mean that those details do not matter, some do! Two of
the main ones are the permissions system that is simpler in Nuxeo and more complete in
Alfresco and the mesh asset viewer, also known as DAM (Digital Asset Management) in
Nuxeo that doesn’t exist on Alfresco.
In my opinion, if only using the ECM through CMIS:
If no distribution is required: Alfresco has more permissions allowing more flexibility
so it should be the best option.
If workload distribution is required: Nuxeo free version should be able to answer the
necessity.
If also using the interface that comes with the ECM, Nuxeo is the best option as it
contains some more features than Alfresco, including the very useful DAM viewer.
6.3
Business Process Management
The decision was to use jBPM.
At that time, the latest stable version of jBPM was 6.0.0. It had multiple signs of
“rushed product”. Documentation was incomplete, there was no documentation in the
java interface files, many icons were missing, basic functionalities were missing, and the
list goes on and on...
Some months later, 6.0.1 was released. This one acted more like an alpha or beta
version of the actual product. Many new icons were added (in a maintenance version?!?)
and some new minor features too.
By the time 6.1.0.CR1 was released, I was nearly at the deadline of my trainee program. In my opinion, this version is what 6.0.0 should have been in the first place. It
still had noticeable bugs but they were minor or hard to find. The documentation is more
complete, the java interface documentation is quite clear and quite complete and many
functionalities work well and as expected.
In retrospect, it would have been better to choose an older version (5.4) which was
already used in other projects of Novabase and benefit from better support and an existing
codebase.
After being introduced to Activiti, I can, then, compare jBPM and Activiti.
Both jBPM and Activiti have a very rubust and, mostly, bug-less BPM engine. I was