Download An Environment for Graphical Models

Transcript
Chapter 10
The EH-procedure
By the principles of weak acceptance and weak rejection, coherence, the search space of
all hierarchical models on the contingency table is divided into two sets of models: the
class of minimal acceptable models and the class of maximal rejected models. Hence,
after using the ‘Fast Procedure for Models Search’, the EH-procedure, by Edwards
& Havránek (1985) and Edwards & Havránek (1987) any model can be labeled as
accepted or rejected.
By the EH-procedure the models (or sub-models of a specific base model, the model
SearchBase read by the command READ BASE MODEL hmodel i;) are classified into
two regions A and R: weakly accepted models and weakly rejected models. Weakly
accepted models are models that include an accepted model, and weakly rejected
models are models that are included in a rejected model. In turn, a boundary below
the weakly accepted models and a boundary above the weakly rejected models, the
R-dual DR (A) and the A-dual DA (R) respectively, are fitted.
In CoCo the global search can be started with the accepted class containing the
saturated model and the class of rejected models containing the model with only
main-effects, or any models can be entered into the two classes. The search stops
when either all models in DA (R) \ A are accepted or all models in DR (A) \ R are
rejected.
The search-module is only usable for small tables. The dimension of the table
should not exceed 10 too much. There should not be too many choices between
acceptable models. If there is no clear association between some factors (given others),
i.e., there are many marginal associations but no clear conditional associations, then
all models in DR (A) will be accepted for several fits of DR (A), and the duals will
explode in size, i.e., if one can choose between too many acceptable models. When
the temptation to use this algorithm is the greatest, it should not be used.
If one of the search-commands described in this chapter is used, then the searchmodule is initiated, i.e., initial classes of models and duals are found for the EHprocedure. By default, the saturated model is accepted, and the model with only
main effects is rejected.
112