Download Satellite Phone Comparison Study Final Report

Transcript
The Ultimate Combination
1. Global Coverage
Iridium: The Iridium system uses 66 satellites moving 775 km (482 miles) above the
earth in polar orbits to provide continuous coverage of the entire globe. The satellites
are always moving relative to the surface of the earth. The Iridium satellites typically
appear near the horizon at elevation angles as low as 8º. Consequently, users
sometimes do not have a clear line of sight to the satellites due to obstructions.
The Iridium satellite network is global. However, its universal service claim ignores
the fact that coverage is often denied or disconnected near partial foliage and
buildings. In reality, the Iridium system probably provides less coverage of the Earth
at any time because the Iridium satellites are typically at a low elevation angle and
transmission is blocked. Our experience is that longer calls on Iridium 9555 typically
suffer disconnects, probably because the satellites are moving. For instance, we
were often able to get Iridium service in Alaska but not all of the time. Sometimes we
had to wait for several minutes before a satellite signal was available. We sat at a
picnic table for 45 minutes in an open area and recorded four periods of “searching
for network” that lasted for a total of 9 minutes. We were surprised that the quality of
service was relatively poor for the Iridium system in northern latitudes since the
concentration of satellites is highest nearest the poles.
Inmarsat: Inmarsat uses three geostationary satellites that are positioned to serve all
of the earth except for the extreme polar regions. We can confirm Inmarsat‟s global
coverage claims. IsatPhone Pro worked well in all locations. We obtained strong
connections for IsatPhone Pro in Anchorage and Fairbanks, Alaska and northern
Finland near the Arctic Circle – all areas near the edge of coverage. IsatPhone Pro
worked well near the equator and in mid-latitude locations as well. IsatPhone Pro,
like all satphones, requires a clear transmission path. However, once a suitable
location is selected the satellite does not move and uninterrupted communication is
possible in the middle of built-up areas, trees, or rocky terrain.
Inmarsat coverage is shown in Figure 7. The specific orbit locations are as follows:
Page 14