Download La doctrine, la QPC et le Conseil constitutionnel

La doctrine, la QPC et le Conseil constitutionnel :
quelle distance ? Quelle expertise ?
!
"
$
#
#
#
%
!
#
#
"
'
"&
"
(
)
*
"
+
"
!
,
"
&
-
"
"
$
"
"
""
"
""
"
"
/
* "
"
"
"&
0
"1"
""
2
"
*
.
&
"&
(
!
) "1"
3
"&
"1"
#
"&
""
"
" $
*
#
"
"
"
5
"
#
"
""
!
%
;
'
&
"
6
"
'778 9%8
#
>
:
<'7 %==8
4
0
"
'
$ "
5 "
"
!
"
(
(
)
"
"
1
""
1
)
""
""
.
"
""
9
!
"
" "
8
$
? ! #
"
" "
""
"
@
$ "
""
" "
!
0
A
*
"
" "
" "
"
C
"
"
"1"
$
"1" " &
""
""
" "
!
A
;
0 +
6 H
"
#
E
0
E
E
" "
* "
""
* "
%=9
(* !
!
0
0
" 0
0E
0
!
) !"
) !"
'77=
!
(*
0
0 0
E
=A@9B
" &
!!
C
.
'77@
)
!
E
''G I
"
!
<'77@0@%9 5! %8
(*
0
<@B
)
" "
"
"
'778
@A@
" "
"
""
"1"
!
,! # AB- . 3
(*
'77@
<%%
%' I 0 +
A " '77@ <=7 @
.EEFFF
E
'7%7
"1"
;
B
E 0
#
.: 5
(*
;
: 5
<'= '7%7
"
"
""
"
H !
5
*
D
*
%@
.EEFFF
0
$
'@G9G "
4
0
#
*
""
!
!
, <'=1
@
!
1
*
8
"
#
"
9
B
!
E
"
E
)
0 0
<A
## #
9
$
.
#
!
0
"
"
#
*
"
0
!
*
!
0 $
?
!
"
#
"
(
#
J
""
#
"
)
G
&
"
"&
(
!
""
J
J
.
"
!
"
J
!
J
(
(
" "
)
J
$
J
#
J
)
K
5 "
"
&
J
0"1"
"
&
J
!
J
""
"
&
$ "
J
#
#
"
#"
"
$
J
(
#
#
"&
=
) 4
"
& .(
)
06 5
"
"
"
"
"
:
.
""
L
K
%7
"1"
G
"
%7
"
""
$
=
""
"
"
0"1" )
J
"
!
(M
" &
$ ) !"
'7%% G97
06 5
(*
"
"
!
)
.
(
.
<B '7%'
)
!
J
N
!
OM
8
8
!
#
!
"1"
"
#
#
? !
"
!
"&
#
*
"
&
!
"
0
"
0#0
!
"
#
& ,
-
"& ,
-
*
#
"
"
O *
"
&
# /
"
.
& #
"
"
#
0#0
?
1
#
0
"
O
*
"
? !
*
"
!
#
"1"
"
+
"
"
-
,
/
#
"
#
(
4
)
"
#
%%
? !
#
"
"&
"1"
"
"
#
P
"
%%
+
"
Q
"
.%
& #
#
#
'(
"
)*+*,)**- '7%' A@A
@
"
*
"
- # R
"&
, &
"
"
"
%'
"
"
"
%9
&
(
)
"
*
!
%8
S # !
# 1
%@
"
5
""
/
""
? !
#
0#0
D
"
"
1
"
"
1
"
"
"
!
&
01
"
"
0
$
5&
""
"
"
"
0
"
"
"1"
""
"
"
"
"
T
"
"
"
"&
"
% "
"
'7%7
!
T
#
""
"
C
"
"1"
*
"
"
.
%'
%9
&
;
(
"
""
"
4
)
"
$
#
*
"
&
*
" K
K
"
&
""
"
"
%8
*
%@
! 4
(* !
(*
!
) !"
) !"
%==%
89@
%==7
B%
A
%A
? !%B
%G
"
4
"
"
#
#
""
"
P
!
? ! *
"1"
? ! >
%=
*
&
!
!
""
'7
!
#
5
"
"
1
*
# 1
(? !) *
P
#
.
""
U
'%
""
* ? !
(
!
$
5
)
5 "
""
&
$ "
"
"
""
1 5
"
? !
#
# #
*
# P
#"
!
""
"
""
K
K
"
"&
*
""
$ #
;
%G
D
(?
%=
#
?
;
!
"
E
;
; Q
'7
61"
'%
;
? !
)
E
$
"
+
P
%A
%B
"
6
. /
V
# C
!
"
0"1" "1"
2W""E? !E
#
'7%' .
? !
.EEFFF
"
0
E
0
WA%W%
. X 6
Y
'7%% 8AA
0
0
6
"
"
C+ 3
#
#
""
#
*
B
"
0
/
""
"
"1"
!
"
0
""
0#0
&
*
"
"
#
""
*
"
""
!
!
"
"1"
"
""
#
""
"
? !
"
!
"
"
"
"
"
#
1
5
"
L
OL
? !
"
"
"
1
"
#
1
"
"
01
!
!
#
""
# "
1
0#0
4
? !
#
*
#
"
,Z -
"
"
"
§ I – Une distance imparfaite
*
"1"
0#0
!
"
? ! *
"
,Z -
K
G
''
!
"
"
"
&
$
&
"
"
"
"
"
""
"
K#
"
#
"
0"1"
"
"
0#0
!
!
!
"
&
"
#
,4,Q-
#
&
A - La part du Conseil constitutionnel : la capture de la doctrine universitaire
+
!
(
)
#
D
"
6
#
"
"
#
!
"
.
!
C
"
"
#
*
"
!
#
!
&
&
#
"
"1"
!
"
*
"
!
"
K
#
#
"
*
01
*
!
"
*
"
.
"
"1"
"
*
&
""
(
!
)
J
+
''
;
" &
"
>)
[
"
$"
"
06 5
&
!
# @-
(#
&
) ,( *
"
!
=
:
#
" K
&
0"1" !
"
I"
D
"
"
"
" "
#
#
"
&
"
&
+
"
*
!
/
$
"
*
""
(
)
K
"
""
""
*
"
'9
!
""
C
#
"
#
&
"
""
!
"
& #
!
"
*
01 "
""
" &
""
#
"
"
"
*
"1"
$
K
""
"
"
"
*
&
"
#
"
+
.
/
" K
& ""
"
+
"
1
"
&
/
"
# "1"
0"1"
"
0"1"
.
0
"
O*
"
O
"
"
"
#
" $
0
O5
"
4
0
0
"
'9
"
#
\ 5 #
0
#
O*
%7
"
(
)
"
" " #
"
C
"
"
"
J 0#0
#
"
"
"
0#0
B - La part de la doctrine : la déférence à l’égard de l’institution objet du
discours
5
K
"
*
"
0
"
? !
"
S
"
"
"
"
"
*
#
"
"
"
"
#
"
"
)
"
"
T
#
(
'8
5
"
"
P
!
!
!
(
)
"
4 0
#
"
"
'@
"
'A
'8
!
"
#
? !
#
.
? !
H $
!
"
#
? !
? !
+
"
K
"
"
"
"
"
"
!
"
M
"
"
;
$ &
) 0
"
'@
Q
'A
;
#
'B
(
,
"
1 ( #
. 5 "
K
""
"
!
)
0
.H !
''
D 6
'7%7I 5 3
"
(* !
(* !
5 * $( * !
.
'G
? !
"
&
"
.
"
#
&
&
"
%%
*
" (
)
"
"
!
#
"
"
!
!
"
$
"
\ .(
45 647 6#0
'
9
!
) (
8
'=
) I
(
8
8
? !
!
2
(3
(
!( 8
(
])
)
97
) I
9(
(
""
( $
(
#
$
"
(
(
(
)
(
!
'
"
9%
) I(
4 6
$
9'
) *
"
!
&
"
"
"
*
"
"
&
*
"
#
&
$
$
$
.
"
!
%'@8 I Q 6
* "
(* !
)
,. <%B 'A
5 +"
4 3
(5 P
@ " '7%7
@(*
*
& O) &
<A
'7%7
& B I(
,;
"
!
%'98 I
'G
+
5 "
" .
"
1
.
'=
H !
D 6
97
4 *
# %'@8
9%
Q6
9'
H \ (* !
%' I 4 *
]) ! #
!
(3
/ '7%7
) &
.5P
'7%7
$
) &
& AI (+
"
O* !
<G U '7%7
)
(!
0!
( "
(* !
0* Q
!
'7%7 < %%B
'7%7 8A8
"
. 5 +"
.
O ) . /# # 'B
. !
?
'B
(
0? !
#
+
"
)
'
*
"
"
)
7
"
"
)
$
"
(* !
)
"
& GI(*
)
? !
I6 H
I (*
%A
'7%7) !"
) !#
"# # #'7%7 <G8
" ?
? !.
"
'7%7 <'=
'7%% <%9B
.
%=
"
0
'7%7 88= I X 6
BA%0B=%
) ! #
/ '7%7
) #
K
O4
(* ? !
M
#
)
#
>"
4
1
%A
'7%7) !"
<
"
<B
#
,A9
'7%7
8@G
#
%'
"
0#0
!
*
!
"
"
#
? !
+
&"
!
*
"
? !
0#0
"
0 $
" "
!
!
"
&
"
& #
"
" "
#
"
1
1
"
? !
#
01
"
T
O 61"
"
#
99
"
? !
01
/
S
!
"
"
"
!
""
T
"
#
O *
!
" >
"
*
!
(M
1
)
? !
!
"
""
? !98 *
"
$
*
,
M
U
,
01
- *
"
$
"
)
"
"
&
P
"
5
"
$ ,
"
"
"
(
#
"
01
5
# #
#
#
#
!
#
99
!
*
:
"
"
#
'7%7 <'G9G %%%
98
;
3
A%0%
*
""
"
K ""
""
!
^
#
"
"
"
< '77=0%@'9
4 "
"
%7
"
@
'77=
%9
&"
"
""
"
#
#
1
#
1
"
#
1
#
#
+
#
"
!
"
"
#
#
P
#
*
#
§ II – Une expertise à construire
*
""
"
"
"
"
"
""
#
*
& "
$
* ? !
$ "
"
0#0
"
*
"
"
"
$
1
*
1
"
"
!
"
"
"
*
00
#
#
,Z *
.
"
,Z -
A - Renoncer à la vérité du discours doctrinal
*
&
O *
$ "
"
"
#
#
"
&
"
! ""
*
J 0#0
#
*
"
"
%8
"
"
?
(
"
"
"
)
$
"
(
)
O5
"
"
"
$#
"1" "
"
*
,
""
"
#
C
/
""
&
"
-
"
!
5
#
"1"
1 #
"
#
!
#
5
$ &"
"
#
"
R
"
K
$
"
#
$
& "
""
"
"
0"1"
#
!
"
"
# "1"
0"1" #
" K
#
"
#
"
"
K
&
#
!
"
#
"
""
Q
*
S #
H
0
""
$
? !
"
"
#
!
!
!
2
""
+
!
#
#
"
""
1
"
*
"
"
""
"
"
"
#
#
"
%@
"
""
"1"
"
#
!
"
" #
&
"
""
*
"
(
&
)
*
"
"
$ "
*
1
"1"
"
*
"
"
""
1
*
#
"
*
#
1
"
*
#
"
#
"
01
#
#
$
#
"
? !
#
#
"
"
!
"
B - Expliciter l’apport de la parole doctrinale
*
&
"
"
? !
"
(
)
"
0
O?
.
5
0 (1
0#0
K
0"1"
"
#
)O ?
"1"
#
0
O ?
#1
"
O
"
"
"
1
"&
*
"
"
.
1
&
&
#
+
"
#
.
%A
1
"
#
*
"
#
#
*
#
0"1"
"
$
.
"
>
01
"
$
$
I
"
"
,
#
01
"
>- *
"& +
0
"
" 1
#
"
*
# "
"
# "
" K
U
#
"
#
1
*
1
!
""
"1"
#
#
"
#
4 0
#
"
"
# "1"
?
01
"
"
"
""
*
"
"
"
*
"
*
"
"
"
#
+
"
"
"
"1"
"
""
"
"
"
" "
"
&
5
P
I
# %77 !<
"
"
"
#
"
1
*
1
0"1"
"
%B
4
1
1
4
&
1
"
"1"
0
" "
*
1
(
1
K
)9@
$
"
*
&
&
S #
#
*
"
#
"1"
& !
#
"
5
#
"1"
"
#
"
"
*
"
"
"
"
#
"
"
&
&" "
"
$
#
"
"
1
'7 "
"
R
*
C
AB= 2"
*$ #
AB 2"E
#
"
"
&"
"
*
1
CH;
" $
# Q
"
"
"
97
"
$
"1"
#
#
#=
"
"
"
"
"
40
!
("
"
#
)
"
"
!
"
O *
AG
"
"
"
"
&
"
$ "
1
$ "
#
4
$ "
"
! 4
%==G
(5
87A
#
*
"
"
"
"
9@
1
5
%G780%G==0%=== ,
-) ! #
/
%G
"
01
"
* ? !
, -
"
""
#
"
"
*
"
#
"
"
#
"1"
"
X
"
64HD:D
# M
6
V
"
"&
C
%!