Download Computerized Building Energy Simulation Handbook

Transcript
Preface
The truth is, I have a hard time with conventional wisdom. As I have begun to mature (no, I'm not
going to reveal my age), it seems that about half of the conventional wisdom I encounter about how
the world works seems to be exactly backwards from the way things really are. Yet the world at large
seems to largely continue believing the conventional wisdom, apparently without a clue as to the real
truth. A (hopefully) quick example, perhaps, will make my point clear. Most people believe, I think
that people and businesses without insurance are at a great risk and get "destroyed" when an
"accident" happens and they don't have insurance to pay for the damages they have caused. However,
in my personal experience in performing expert witness services, it is only the people with insurance
that end up paying the bill when a lawsuit is initiated. What happens is what I call the "nose count."
When a settlement conference is held with the defendants in a case by, say a Special Master, on cases
I've seen, all the defendants and their counsel come together in a big conference room. The Special
Master will say something like, "well, we have a million dollar claim, there are 10 defendants in the
room, that means that you are each 'in' for $100,000." Then the special master will ask who doesn't
have insurance coverage. Perhaps five defendants will raise their hands, and the special will say
something like, "you can go.'' After half the room has cleared, the Special Master will clear his throat
and then say, "OK, now you are each 'in' for $200,000"—and the conference will continue. I swear,
this, or something very much like it, has happened on almost every one of my cases. It seems, in civil
suits, that the ability to pay is the only thing that determines whether you're culpable. The obvious
conclusion is that carrying insurance, in many circumstances, is like hanging a sign around your neck
that says "sue me"—and that the only sensible course is to not carry insurance—which runs contrary
to the "conventional" wisdom.
Well, in the field of building simulation, I feel like the same thing is true. It seems like most of the
world's conventional wisdom is to treat building simulation like it's sort of an academic exercise and
as though it really doesn't make any difference whether the model of a building accurately reflects
reality, just as long as it looks good.
A specific experience in this regard stimulated the creation of the seminar we teach for the
Association of Energy Engineers, which is the basis for this book. We do consulting for a wide range
of people including utility companies. Not too long ago we did a review of a study that had been done
by a design/build contractor. They had done a computer simulation of a building and estimated savings,
and turned it in to the utility company for a rebate. The utility company thought the documentation
looked "fishy" and asked that we review the project. In reviewing that project it became apparent that
the contractor knew very little about how to do building simulation and yet this was the foundation for
their request for a rebate and funding for a project. We ended up re-doing the model for that particular
building and it turned out that the contractor's estimated savings were about twice what it should have
been. In other words, a realistic savings figure was about half of what the contractor had told the
customer and the utility company. We concluded that the problem wasn't intent, as the energy services
company doing the work really did intend to do a good job—but they just didn't have the skills to
tackle the task—yet this was their "stock in trade"! What we also realized was that you can go to the
Trane Company, or perhaps Carrier or perhaps some consultants that teach the DOE-2 program and
you can learn all about their a particular software product. However, you don't learn very much about
what it takes to make the whole process of building simulation work. To create real, viable, and